Rare illuminated manuscript of the text of the Statutes of the royal French chivalric Order of St. Michel by an artist in the circle of the Master of the Paris Entries (perhaps identical with the Parisian illuminator Etienne Collaud). Whereas many manuscripts of the Statutes must once have existed, because each knight received a copy, no manuscript of the text has appeared at auction since 1920. Only a few extant copies are illuminated with frontispieces.
1. Most likely from a series of twelve manuscripts documented as having been ordered by the court of Francis I, king of France (1515-47), for distribution to knights of the Order. Books of chivalric statutes were to be returned to the Order on the knight's death. The documents date the manuscripts between 1523 and 1528.
2. Hemricourt de Ramioul, c. 1810, from Belgium, Liege, his printed armorial bookplate on the front pastedown, along with shelf mark A./III./69 (see Armorial belge de bibliophiles, vol. 2, Brussels, 1886).
3. Howel Wills (1845-1901), of Baillol College, Oxford, and the Inner Temple, London, later resident in Florence, with his printed label; his sale, London, Sotheby's, 11 July 1894, lot 1104, bought by Ellis.
f. 7, full-page miniature showing the king of France (Louis XI, initial founder of the order but meant to represent any king of France, in this case Francis I), holding the scepter and main-de-justice, enthroned attended by ten members of his court all wearing the collars of the Order of St.-Michel, with a tiled floor, curtains behind and gothic windows, architectural framing border including marble pillars emblazoned with gold fleur-de-lys, swags of leaves suspended at top.
When the Order of St. Michel was founded, the famous Jean Fouquet was commissioned to paint the title miniature of the Statutes showing the king presiding over the knights (Paris, BnF, fr. 19819). This exquisite miniature serves as the ultimate prototype for most of the copies of the Statutes. The double strand of cockleshells in the present miniature shows the later form of the collar which had changed by c. 1520. In fact, the collar represented here is found also in BnF, MS fr. 19815, another manuscript of the same date from the official series.
The style of the frontispiece miniature of the present manuscript, roughly based on the Fouquet model, is that of artists working in the circle of the French court circa 1520, especially those in the circle of the Master of the Paris Entries (see Orth, below). The Master of the Paris Entries, so named for his work on the funeral books of Anne of Brittany and the Parisian entries of Mary Tudor (both 1514) and Claude de France (1517), was one of the leaders of a very busy group of illuminators. "His work is recognizable through its recurring physical types, the clumsy yet decisive rhythm of movement, strong outlines, sketchy modeling over unmodulated color areas, primitive spatial compositions, and other traits that point to speed of execution" (Orth, pp. 21-22). His work "can be traced through the 1520s" (Orth, p. 31).
A review of the documentation on manuscripts of the Statutes leads to further observations regarding the identity of the artist(s). Our manuscript is very likely one of a series referred to in two contemporary documents transcribed by Durrieu in his 1911 study: in 1523 and then 1528, Antoine Tavart, the Order's herald, commissioned and paid a Parisian artist named Etienne Collaud to illustrate a total of twelve copies of the Order's Statutes:
Cette induction se trouve confirmée par les documents qui nous parlent de semblables exemplaires, commandes par la Cour de France pour être ensuite distribués aux chevaliers de l'Ordre de Saint-Michel. Dans une quittance du 22 janvier 1523, le héraut roi d'armes de l'Ordre, qui était alors Antoine Tavart "confesse avoir reçu de Maitre Nicolas de Neuville ... la somme de LXXXVI escus d'or soleil pour icelle somme estre baillee aux escrivains, enlumineurs et relieurs qui feront XII livres en parchemin, esquels seront declaréz, contenuz et escritz les articles, statuts et ordonnances dudict ordre". [...] Par une autre quittance, "Estienne Collaud, enlumineur, demeurant a Paris, confesse avoir reçu de Maitre Antoine Tavart, chevalier, roy d'armes de l'ordre et valet de chambre du roy, la somme de LXXII livres tournois pour avoit fait par ledit Collaud et livré VI livres contenans les chapitres, statuts et ordonnances de l'ordre du roy" (Paris, BnF, Coll. Clairambault MS. 1242, f. 1630). Le susdit enlumineur Etienne Collaud reçut encore le 10 septembre 1528 une nouvelle somme de 72 livres tournois pour le paiement de six autres livres semblables...." (Durrieu, 1911, p. 31-32).
Might the Master of the Paris Entries thus be identical with Etienne Collaud? Although there is more than one style among the manuscripts that can be identified from the official series, the convergence of the style of the Master of the Paris Entries and the documented name of Etienne Collaud is nevertheless intriguing and leads to the tantalizing hypothesis that the two artists may be identical.
Avril, F. and N. Reynaud. Les Manuscrits à peintures en France 1440-1520, Paris, Bibliothèque nationale, 1992-93.
Boulton, D'Arcy Jonathan Dacre. The Knights of The Crown: The Monarchical Orders of Knighthood in Later Medieval Europe, 1325-1520, Woodbridge, Suffolk (Boydell Press), 1987. Second revised edition (paperback), 2000.
Briçonnet, André. Statuts de l'Ordre de Saint-Michel, [Paris], Imprimerie royale, 1725.
Codici miniati delle Biblioteca Oratoriana dei Girolamini di Napoli, curated by A. Putaturo Murano and A. Perriccioli Saggese, Naples, 1995,under no. 35.
Delaissé, L.M.J. & James Marrow & John de Wit. The James De Rothschild Collection at Waddesdon Manor: Illuminated Manuscripts, London (Office du Livre for The National Trust), 1977.
Durrieu, P. "Les manuscrits des Statuts de l'Ordre de Saint-Michel," in Bulletin de la Société française de reproduction de manuscrits à peintures, Paris, 1911, pp. 17-47. (Study of the extantcopies).
Durrieu, P. "Les manuscrits à peintures de la bibliothèque de sir Thomas Phillipps à Cheltenham," Bibliothèque de l'Ecole des chartes, 1889.
Dutilleux, Adolphe. "Notice sur un manuscrit du XVIe siècle, contenant le texte des statuts de l'ordre de Saint-Michel, appartenant à la bibliothèque communale de Saint-Germain-en-Laye", in Mémoires de la Société des sciences morales, des lettres et des arts de Seine-et-Oise, vol. XIV,
Favyn, André. Le Théâtre d'Honneur et de Chevalerie ou l'Histoire des ordres militaires des roys et princes... de l'institution des armes et blasons... duels, joustes et tournois et de tout ce qui concerne le faict du chevalier de l'ordre..., Paris, R. Foüet, 1620.
Gabriel, A. "A Statute Book of the Order of St. Michael in the Pierpont Morgan Library, New York City," in Miscellanea codicologica F. Masai dedicata, Ghent, 1979, pp. 481-89.
Lyte, H.C. Maxwell. Catalogue of Manuscripts and other Objects in the Museum of the Public Record Office, London, 1905.
Orth, Myra. "Dedicating Women: Manuscript Culture in the French Renaissance and The Cases of Catherine d'Amboise and Anne de Graville", Journal of the Early Book Society, 1997, pp.. 17-47.
Chivalric Orders site, mostly written and maintained by Guy Stair Sainty. Best site on the subject.